When you’re planning a new commercial build or a major renovation, the materials you choose define the longevity, safety, and functionality of your space. One of the most common debates we encounter at South Coast Improvement Company (SCIC) revolves around a fundamental structural choice: plaster vs drywall.

It might seem like a small detail in the grand scheme of a multi-million dollar senior living facility or a university campus upgrade, but your choice of wall system impacts everything from fire resistance to long-term maintenance costs. Whether you manage a historic property or are breaking ground on a modern office complex, understanding these differences is critical.

Choosing the Right Wall System Matters

In the world of commercial construction, walls do more than just divide rooms. They provide sound insulation for privacy, offer fire resistance for safety, and serve as the canvas for your interior design. While drywall installation has become the standard for speed and cost-efficiency, plaster walls tend to offer benefits that modern materials struggle to replicate.

So, how do you decide? The answer depends on your building’s purpose. A high-traffic hospital corridor has different needs than a boutique hotel lobby or a historic university library. At SCIC, we help clients navigate these decisions daily, ensuring the final build aligns with both their budget and their long-term operational goals.

Plaster vs Drywall: Key Differences in Commercial Buildings

To make an informed decision, you first need to understand the key differences between these two materials.

Historically, plaster was the gold standard. Before World War II, almost every building featured walls made of wood lath and lime plaster. However, the post-war building boom demanded faster, cheaper solutions, which is when drywall sheets (also known as gypsum board) largely replaced plaster.

Today, both plaster and drywall have their place. Drywall panels are pre-manufactured sheets consisting of a gypsum core sandwiched between thick paper. They are screwed onto wall studs, and the seams are taped and finished with joint compound.

Plaster, on the other hand, is a wet material applied in multiple layers over a base, such as metal lath or cement board. It cures to a hard, dense finish that becomes part of the wall itself rather than just a surface covering.

Is Plaster Still Used in Commercial Construction?

You might be wondering, “Is plaster even an option anymore?” The answer is yes, though it is less common in standard commercial builds. Plaster installation is often reserved for high-end projects, historic renovations, or facilities requiring superior durability.

What Plaster Offers:

• Superior Soundproofing: The density of plaster provides excellent sound dampening qualities, making it ideal for executive offices or luxury hospitality suites.
• Durable Finish: Plaster creates a rock-hard, smooth surface that resists dents and dings better than standard drywall.
• Design Flexibility: It allows for intricate designs, curves, and custom textures that are difficult to achieve with flat panels.

However, plaster requires a specific skill set. It is a labor intensive installation process that demands skilled craftsmen. Because it is a wet application, it is also a time consuming process compared to hanging drywall, which can impact project timelines.

Drywall Installation in Residential and Commercial Buildings

For the vast majority of modern projects, drywall installation is the go-to choice. It is efficient, scalable, and cost-effective. A typical drywall job involves hanging the panels, taping the joints, and applying a finish coat.

Benefits of Drywall:

• Speed: Drywall sheets cover large areas quickly, accelerating the construction schedule.
• Cost-Effective: Lower material costs and reduced labor time mean a lower cost per square foot.
• Versatility: Modern drywall comes in various types, including moisture-resistant and fire-rated options.
• Ease of Repair: Need to run new wiring or fix a leak? Cutting and patching a section of drywall is far simpler than repairing a plaster wall.

However, standard drywall does have limitations. It can have a hollow sound if not properly insulated, and in high traffic areas, it is prone to impact damage.

Fire Resistance in Plaster and Drywall Systems

Safety is our top priority at SCIC, especially when working in occupied spaces like healthcare facilities and senior living communities. Fire resistance is a critical factor in the plaster vs drywall debate.

Both plaster and drywall offer fire protection, but they achieve it differently. The gypsum core in drywall contains chemically combined water, which is released as steam when exposed to high heat, slowing the spread of fire. Type X drywall is specifically manufactured with glass fibers to increase its fire resistant rating.

Plaster is naturally fire resistant due to its density and lack of air gaps. When applied over metal lath, it forms a highly effective barrier against flames. In many historic buildings, existing plaster walls provide excellent fire protection, which is why preserving them during renovation is often a smart safety strategy.

Sound Insulation and Wall Performance

Privacy is a major concern for our clients, whether they run a medical clinic or a university dormitory. When comparing sound insulation, plaster walls tend to outperform standard drywall.

The sheer mass of a plaster wall blocks sound transmission effectively. While drywall can feel thin and hollow, plaster feels solid. However, modern construction techniques have bridged this gap. By using fiberglass insulation, resilient channels, and multiple layers of specialized sound-dampening drywall, we can achieve acoustic performance that rivals traditional plaster.

Comparing the Installation Process and Labor Costs

Budget is always a driving force in commercial construction. Here, the difference is stark.

Plaster installation is an art form. It requires applying a base coat, a scratch coat, and a finish coat, with drying time in between. This labor intensive process translates to significantly higher labor costs and a longer schedule.

Drywall installation is faster and more standardized. Skilled labor for drywall is readily available, and the process is predictable. For large-scale projects like affordable housing developments or retail build-outs, the efficiency of drywall is unmatched.

However, upfront cost isn’t the only metric. In a historic building where removing wood lath and plaster would destroy the property’s character and require extensive demolition, repairing the existing plaster might actually be the more economical and respectful choice.

Plaster Installation for Historic Buildings

As a company with deep expertise in historic renovations, we know that some buildings demand respect for their original materials. In historic properties, swapping plaster for drywall can sometimes lead to issues with structural integrity or moisture regulation.

Often, we utilize veneer plaster for these projects. This involves applying a thin layer of plaster over a special gypsum base (blue board). It offers the hard, durable surface and look of traditional plaster with a speedier installation time closer to that of drywall. It bridges the gap between old-world quality and modern construction timelines.

Plaster and Drywall: Making the Right Choice

So, which wall system is right for your project?

• Choose Drywall If: You need a cost-effective solution, are working on a tight timeline, need easy access to utilities behind the walls, or are building a standard commercial space.
• Choose Plaster (or Veneer Plaster) If: You are renovating a historic property, require exceptional durability in high-traffic zones, need superior soundproofing without complex wall assemblies, or want a high-end, seamless aesthetic.

At South Coast Improvement Company, we don’t believe in a one-size-fits-all approach. We assess your building’s specific needs—from fire resistance requirements to acoustic goals—and recommend the solution that delivers the best value.

Partner with Our Expert Construction Team

Whether you are dealing with flaking paint on century-old plaster or planning a ground-up build with miles of interior walls, you need a partner who understands the nuances of construction materials.

We are a single-source partner that stays with you from the initial assessment through to final project delivery. Our 90% repeat business rate speaks to our commitment to getting it right.

Ready to start your next project with confidence?

Request a Free Consultation or Schedule a Project Assessment Today to discuss the best materials for your building. Let’s build something lasting, together.

 

---

---